72% of 2025 child fatality referrals had prior CPS history, up from 36%
All Virginia News
Virginia's child welfare agency reported that nearly three in four child fatality referrals in 2025 had "prior CPS history," up from about one in three for 2024. Its one-page score card doesn't define the term or explain the change.
The Virginia Department of Social Services' 2025 Safety Score Card, which covers calendar year 2025, lists 72% for a measure labeled "Child Fatality Referrals With Prior CPS History." The 2024 Safety Score Card lists 36% for the same label. Both cards are one page. Neither gives the number of fatality referrals behind the percentage or defines "prior CPS history."
Each card says it measures several outcomes among referrals found valid for a CPS response, and lists this one under "What's Being Measured" as "Child Fatalities With Previous Referrals." The cards don't say how far back a previous referral can be, whether screened-out referrals count, or whether the fatality referrals were later founded.
A second fatality measure on the cards moved the other way. "Child Fatality Referrals With High Risk Level" was 36% on the 2024 card and 24% on the 2025 card. On the 2024 card, the prior-history and high-risk figures are both 36%.
Both cards carry the same sentence in their "What This Means" section: "We are deeply concerned that many children who experience harm had prior CPS involvement, and we are committed to strengthening how we respond to repeat referrals and known risk factors." The file names of both cards on the DSS website still include the word "draft."
DSS's annual death investigation reports use a different measure, covering a state fiscal year rather than a calendar year and counting only deaths found to be caused by abuse or neglect. In fiscal 2024, 23 of the 41 families in founded child death cases, 56%, "had prior or active child welfare involvement," according to the SFY 2024 report (Executive Summary, printed page 2; Table 16, page 12). The report defines prior involvement as the alleged abuser, victim child or siblings having previously been the subject of a family assessment, investigation, in-home services or foster care case, including any case open at the time of death.
Earlier editions reported 27 of 38 families, or 71%, in fiscal 2023 (SFY 2023 report, printed page 2) and 28 of 54 families, or 52%, in fiscal 2022 (SFY 2022 report, printed page 2).
The death reports and the score cards are not interchangeable. One counts founded deaths by fiscal year using a written definition. The other counts fatality referrals by calendar year without one. The death reports put the share of founded deaths with prior involvement between about half and about seven in 10 in each of the past three fiscal years. The 2024 score card's 36% is well below that range, and the 2025 card's 72% is near the top of it.
No score card, death report or fact sheet on the DSS CPS reports page explains why the score card figure rose from 36% to 72%, or whether the way it is calculated changed between years.
2024 2025 abuse agency between care case Cases child child fatalities child protective services child welfare Children concerned data quality death definition Department each explain explains Families family fiscal fiscal year fiscal years foster care founded High history in-home services investigation measures Moved Near neglect outcomes previous previous prior CPS history referral repeat referrals Response safety Safety Score Card services social social services summary table term VDSS victim Virginia Virginia Department of Social Services Virginia's website well whether
All Virginia News is published by ALL VIRGINIA NEWS, LLC. How we're funded · Corrections · Ethics