Richmond's insurer sues city, says it owes nothing on $2 million library railing verdict

Illustration of a columned stone library with wide front steps and a black metal porch railing broken and bent in the middle.

The City of Richmond's insurer is suing the city, arguing it owes nothing toward a $2 million jury verdict awarded to a man who was hurt when a railing gave way at the Main Library downtown, The Richmonder reported Wednesday.

The case is a dispute over who pays for a fall on Dec. 16, 2024. Two men, Paul Buck and Joseph Ashely Max, were leaning on a metal railing on the library's front porch along Franklin Street when it failed, sending both about 6 feet to the ground, according to court records and depositions described by The Richmonder.

Injuries and two lawsuits

Buck suffered five broken ribs, a broken collarbone, a torn finger tendon and a knee injury, along with fluid in his lung, injuries that led to several hospital stays. Max suffered multiple herniated discs in his back, according to court records.

Both men sued the city, saying Richmond allowed the railing to deteriorate until it failed. Buck settled out of court in December 2025. The terms were confidential, but city spokesperson Ross Catrow told The Richmonder the city paid $1.1 million. Virginia courts have held that settlement amounts paid by local governments are subject to disclosure under the state Freedom of Information Act.

Max took his case to trial, and in July a jury awarded him $2 million plus interest. The city intends to appeal the verdict.

"It's a large verdict," Gray Broughton, one of Max's attorneys, told The Richmonder. "But I think if we asked ourselves, 'Would we accept $2 million to go through that ourselves?' I think the answer would probably be no."

Insurer says city broke the policy

Richmond, like many Virginia localities, gets liability coverage through VACorp, a self-insurance risk pool for local governments. The pool helps members defend personal injury and property damage claims and covers some of the cost of payouts that do not involve criminal acts.

In September, VACorp sued both the city and Max. The insurer says Richmond violated its coverage agreement by admitting liability in the case "without any advice or consent" from VACorp. The city's filings this summer stated that it was not disputing liability, only the amount owed.

"The City did not obtain any consent at all to admit liability," wrote Johneal White, an attorney representing VACorp. As a result, the insurer argues, it "has no duty to indemnify the City for the amount of the verdict, at all," and no obligation to keep paying for the city's defense if an appeal goes forward.

City attorneys Monica Malouf and Pete Johnson deny that Richmond broke the agreement. In a recent filing they argued the city "provided proper notice" to the insurer and that VACorp had "waived its ability to enforce the clause of the contract requiring consent for admission of liability." The city also disputes the insurer's claim that it has no further duty to defend Richmond or cover any part of the award.

Catrow said the city "can't comment on active litigation." VACorp did not respond to The Richmonder's questions.

Plaintiff says his award should stand

Max argues that because he was not a party to any contract between the city and its insurer, there is no legal basis to reduce or hold up the amount the jury awarded him.

"Ultimately, it's either going to be the city of Richmond that's going to foot that bill, or it's going to be VACorp that's going to foot that bill," Broughton said. "But our view is that it's a good verdict."

Together, the settlement and the verdict add up to more than $3 million in claims tied to a single railing failure. If the insurer prevails, the city could be left to cover the jury award without help from its risk pool, pending the outcome of Richmond's appeal.

Richmond is an independent city in the Richmond region.

Richmond city government Freedom of Information Act Insurance jury verdict Lawsuit liability Richmond Richmond Public Library VACorp

All Virginia News is published by ALL VIRGINIA NEWS, LLC. How we're funded · Corrections · Ethics

2026-11-17 · d9ba2cc