Virginia and D.C. sue to stop 250-foot arch near Arlington National Cemetery
Virginia and the District of Columbia have gone to federal court to stop construction of a proposed 250-foot triumphal arch in Memorial Circle, the traffic circle at the Virginia end of Arlington Memorial Bridge near Arlington National Cemetery. Federal officials have said work on the arch could start as early as this week.
Virginia Attorney General Jay Jones and D.C. Attorney General Brian Schwalb filed the lawsuit on Saturday, Oct. 31, according to a news release from the Virginia Office of the Attorney General. The complaint says the defendants announced they would begin building "as soon as November 5" and calls the project "flagrantly unlawful."
The legal arguments
The complaint's main argument is that Congress never authorized the arch. It cites the Commemorative Works Act and a separate federal statute, 40 U.S.C. § 8106, which bar new monuments and structures on federal land in the capital without express or specific congressional approval. It also argues that the arch would violate the Height of Buildings Act, which generally caps buildings in the District at 130 feet. The proposed arch would be nearly twice that.
The two attorneys general also claim violations of the Administrative Procedure Act, the National Environmental Policy Act and the National Historic Preservation Act, saying federal officials failed to weigh alternatives and consult as required, WDBJ reported.
The filing also describes practical harm to the region. According to the Associated Press, via PBS News, the states argue that the site "sits at the center of a major traffic artery between the District and Virginia" and that three years of construction would snarl traffic, send pollution and stormwater runoff into the Potomac and interfere with emergency services.
"President Trump's illegal vanity project is an affront to this hallowed ground and the extraordinary sacrifices it represents," Jones said in his office's release.
The administration's case
The White House defends the arch as a tribute to veterans and a landmark for the nation's 250th anniversary. "It will serve as a gateway to Arlington National Cemetery for veterans, the families of the fallen, and all Americans alike," White House spokesman Davis Ingle said in an email quoted by the AP.
Speaking to reporters Saturday night, President Donald Trump said the arch "is very important militarily for Washington, D.C., and our country," the AP reported. He added that it does not matter whether the site is in "Virginia, Maryland, or Washington" because the region needs it.
The government filed a 106-page plan on Friday describing a structure more than 12 stories tall, topped by a large winged bronze Lady Liberty holding a torch with an eternal flame, according to the AP. The plan includes an observation deck, offices, elevators and a "fire command center," along with traffic changes in the area. The administration has said it would seek final approval at Thursday's meeting of the National Capital Planning Commission.
What happens next
U.S. District Judge Tanya Chutkan combined the states' lawsuit with an earlier case brought by three Vietnam War veterans and an architectural historian, and she ordered joint briefing, the AP reported. At a hearing Friday, Chutkan said she would move quickly but did not immediately rule on whether to halt the project. Like the original plaintiffs, Virginia and D.C. are asking for a temporary restraining order.
Administration lawyer Robert Stander told the court the arch was "absolutely a high priority project" and that a court order would impede the government's work, according to the AP.
Arlington County America 250 Arlington National Cemetery attorney general Jay Jones Lawsuit Memorial Circle Triumphal Arch Trump administration
All Virginia News is published by ALL VIRGINIA NEWS, LLC. How we're funded · Corrections · Ethics